Thread:Gu4n/@comment-2088849-20200729080650/@comment-27069677-20200815191123

Hi there, thanks for getting back in touch with me. Good to hear you've set up the poll. What was the response of the other administrators to my proposal?

I think it's a little unabashed to include your proposal immediately in the poll without discussing it with me beforehand. You see, ever since I adopted the Gagharv wiki I've been waiting for my copy of the Gagharv Trilogy Memoir Book to arrive (its shipment got delayed due to COVID-19 measures) so I could start the wiki in earnest. It actually happened to arrive earlier today and I'm looking forward to use it to flesh out the wiki like I've been doing with the Kiseki series and books. For the same reason I started the Kiseki wiki five years ago, I also adopted the Gagharv wiki this year: to start from a clean slate, rather than first verify and include sources of content on the Legend of Heroes wiki. In other words, I rather start from scratch than starting by verifying and/or editing what's already there -- meaning, I'm not yet willing to merge the Gagharv wiki yet.

Furthermore, the Falcom Wiki Alliance is an initiative not only to cross-promote Falcom wikis, but also to vouch for its quality. While I respect the work that has gone into it in the past, I cannot vouch for the quality of the Legend of Heroes wiki as-is (nor speak for the Ys wiki admins). This also means that both the Kiseki and Ys wiki admins will invite you (or other Legend of Heroes wiki admins) to join the Falcom Wiki Alliance once we're convinced the content is more valid than it is right now and, arguably more important, verifiable. You might want to reflect this in the Grand Notice you've added to the Legend of Heroes wiki main page. You're more than welcome to join our Discord server, though!

Finally, the options in the poll could be phrased better, especially since my initial proposal was be to make the Legend of Heroes wiki a Dragon Slayer wiki for the games listed on aforementioned Wikipedia page. Besides, the https://dragonslayer.fandom.com/ URL already redirects to the Legend of Heroes wiki. A Dragon Slayer wiki would also be more clearly defined than 'a wiki with neither Gagharv nor Kiseki games'.

Oh- and it's not clear how people can follow up on 'Other'. If, say, 500 people vote 'Other', you still don't know what they want.

Please consider my feedback.